This post is by our regular library correspondent, Dr Karen McAulay. In this post Karen asks: where and when do you do your best thinking? Are libraries the answer?
Recently I read a blog post by Richard Watson, in which he reported that he had once asked a thousand people when and where they did their best thinking. And guess what? Quiet, distraction free places won, hands down.
I must admit that my favourite was, “37,000 feet and half way into a gin and tonic”, but let’s face it, that precise combination of circumstances happens infrequently for most of us! Similarly, although I find that a single glass of white wine beside the computer at 1.30 am is actually very conducive to the writing of dissertation chapters, I do agree that it’s not a good idea to make a habit of such nocturnal activity.
But about halfway through his blogpost, Richard got onto the subject of libraries. He mentioned the plight of some public libraries who seem to be struggling with a feeling that they’re irrelevant to a large percentage of the population. I sat up and paid attention when he stated, quite categorically, that in his opinion libraries should stop trying to be Starbucks and instead cultivate the quiet stillness that is so hard to find elsewhere: “We need to preserve silent spaces”, he said. And he meant not just in libraries – they were just one example.
Now, it would be easy for me to leap onto my soapbox here. I am, after all, a librarian. I personally love deeply quiet research libraries. My favourite place in the whole of Glasgow is the Special Collections at the top of Glasgow University Library. What could be nicer than being twelve floors up, with fabulous views over the city and beyond, and – inevitably – an absorbing historic text on the desk in front of me? If it’s sunny, the views are especially fabulous. If it’s a howling gale or even a tumultuous storm, it’s still a lovely comfortable haven from which to observe it behind glass! It’s all the nicer knowing that mobile phones aren’t likely to ring, voices will be subdued, and everyone else will be working with the same level of concentration as my own. Is it any wonder I like studying there?
Now, my own library – well, the one where I’m a subject librarian – has a very different atmosphere. I work in a conservatoire. I wouldn’t say it was like Fame Academy, but our students are very sociable, like working together, and interact with each other almost constantly. Even our research is ‘practice-based’, which means there are lots of composers and performers (although the composers are likely to be at home or in a music studio.)
The only time you get deep stillness in our library is when there’s hardly anyone there… And for that reason, we have a ‘Silent Study Zone’ in a glazed room at the far end of the library, so that the hermits can get peace while the extroverts are busy interacting. It’s still not like Starbucks, though. We don’t mind covered drinks being brought in, but mugs of coffee aren’t welcome and there certainly aren’t any cookies!
If you’re a research student or lecturer reading this, you may already be shuddering at the thought of such a buzzing atmosphere. But rest assured, we do pounce if groups of students are getting particularly over-excited; singers attempting to sing-along-a-CD are shushed; and – most importantly – regular user surveys confirm that the vast majority of our readers like the library just the way it is!
Recent postings on The Thesis Whisperer have reflected upon places where we like to work. And the ‘Shut Up and Write’ movement is proof enough that not everyone needs total silence in which to work. Sometimes a gentle background noise is quite soothing, so long as it’s not intrusive – and here’s the crunch – so long as we aren’t required to interact with it. If you can sit and write with a few friends, comfortable in the knowledge that they’re not going to interrupt you with chatter, but equally that you expect everyone to be writing rather than checking texts and Twitter, then you’re well set-up to get some meaningful work done.
So actually, I don’t think this ‘where do you do your best thinking?’ question has any single best answer. Rather, I think you need that indefinable combination of relative peace and quiet, an absence of other distractions, and a bit of self-discipline. Where do you get your best ideas? Is a quiet library your idea of heaven – or not? Now, who’s going to suggest some really imaginative, maybe unusual places for getting those creative juices flowing?
Office or cafe – which is the better workspace?